Key Highlights
- Eddie Murphy reignites discussion on David Spade’s controversial ‘Saturday Night Live’ joke from 1995
- Murphy describes the joke as ‘racist’ and a ‘cheap shot’ against his career
- Spade reflects on the incident, expressing regret in his memoir
- Murphy’s significant return to ‘SNL’ in 2019 marked a reconciliation
(livesinsight.com) – In the annals of comedy, few names shine brighter than Eddie Murphy. Revered for his trailblazing tenure on ‘Saturday Night Live’ (SNL) from 1980 to 1984, Murphy’s career has been a rollercoaster of remarkable highs and deeply personal lows. One such low came in the form of a joke by fellow comedian David Spade during a 1995 ‘SNL’ segment, which Murphy recently described as ‘racist’ and a ‘cheap shot’. The joke, aired during Spade’s ‘Hollywood Minute’ sketch, poked fun at the perceived decline in Murphy’s career following the box office failure of ‘Vampire in Brooklyn’. Murphy’s reaction to the quip, and his subsequent absence from ‘SNL’ for over three decades, speaks to the complexity of race, fame, and respect within the comedy world. This editorial delves into the intricacies of this high-profile feud, examining Murphy’s and Spade’s perspectives and the broader implications for the comedy landscape.
Origins of the Feud: The ‘Hollywood Minute’ Incident
Eddie Murphy’s illustrious career took a significant hit when David Spade made a biting comment on ‘Saturday Night Live’ in 1995. During the ‘Hollywood Minute’ segment, Spade quipped, ‘Look children, it’s a falling star. Make a wish,’ in reference to Murphy’s career after the film ‘Vampire in Brooklyn’ flopped. This seemingly innocuous joke was received by Murphy as a betrayal from within the ‘SNL’ family. The impact was immediate and profound. Murphy felt that the joke was not just an attack on his career but was laced with racial undertones. ‘It was personal,’ Murphy noted in a recent interview, expressing his hurt over the comment. This incident underscores the challenges faced by Black entertainers in predominantly white industries, where the line between humor and hurt can often blur dangerously.
Murphy’s Response: Racism and Professional Respect
In his recent interview with the New York Times, Murphy did not mince words, calling Spade’s joke ‘racist’ and a ‘cheap shot’. He elaborated on his feelings of betrayal, especially given his pivotal role in ‘SNL’s’ history. ‘The show would have been off the air if I didn’t go back on the show, and now you got somebody from the cast making a crack about my career?’ Murphy questioned. This sentiment reflects a broader issue within the entertainment industry, where successful Black performers often face disproportionate scrutiny and criticism. Murphy’s comments highlight the necessity for respect and acknowledgment of contributions, particularly from those who have paved the way for others.
David Spade’s Perspective: Regret and Reflection
David Spade has also addressed the incident, notably in his 2015 memoir ‘Almost Interesting’. Spade recounted receiving a furious phone call from Murphy after the joke aired, during which Murphy vehemently expressed his anger. Spade admitted to feeling terrible about the joke, acknowledging its insensitivity. ‘I’ve come to see Eddie’s point on this one,’ Spade wrote, reflecting on the pressures of being a comedian and the unintended consequences of humor. This incident serves as a potent reminder of the delicate balance comedians must strike between satire and respect. Spade’s regret signifies a broader cultural shift towards more mindful comedy, where the impact on individuals is carefully considered.
Reconciliation and Moving Forward
Despite the initial fallout, Murphy and Spade have since mended fences. Murphy made a notable return to ‘SNL’ in 2019, hosting an episode with guest appearances from fellow comedy legends Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, and Tracy Morgan. This marked a significant moment of reconciliation, showcasing Murphy’s enduring legacy and his ability to move past old grievances. ‘In the long run, it’s all good,’ Murphy said, emphasizing his current good standing with Spade and ‘SNL’ producer Lorne Michaels. This reconciliation highlights the importance of forgiveness and growth within the entertainment industry, allowing for the evolution of relationships and personal development.
Broader Implications for Comedy and Race
The Murphy-Spade incident is more than just a personal feud; it reflects broader societal issues regarding race, respect, and the role of comedy. Murphy’s accusations of racism against Spade’s joke underscore the persistent challenges Black entertainers face, even from within their own industry. This incident has sparked necessary conversations about the limits of humor and the importance of cultural sensitivity. As comedy continues to evolve, it is crucial for comedians to navigate these complexities with care and respect, ensuring that their work uplifts rather than demeans. Murphy’s journey through this feud and his eventual reconciliation with Spade serves as a powerful example of resilience and the enduring impact of thoughtful, respectful comedy.